So If I wanted a Winged Lion, what animal would I buy in the shop?
Gryphon? Or should I use my Special item thing?

I'm going to go ahead and say pegasus. It's a singular, naturally occurring animal(horse) with wings, which is exactly what a winged lion would be.

I would save the special item for something more unique, as they're harder to come by than pegasus-like creature. :)

I would have more so said to sub a gryphon since it's like a winged lion (minus the talons and head) but I see what Stefan's going for with the natural thing. The pick had confused me more so than it should have.

Honestly, any of the three might work, and they're all the same price. Pegasus just seems better if you're only going for a non-hybrid animal mount, such as a lion, with wings.

awesome! thanks you guys!

No problem. :)